The Eager Alligator

woman holding dried flower

The Eager Alligator Welcomes You!

Custom Cookies and Monthly Bake Box Treats

Order

Delicious Customizable Cookie Packages

Order Your Favorites

Shop
Three open boxes containing different varieties of cookies, such as chocolate chip, double chocolate, and funfetti, placed on a speckled countertop.
Three open boxes containing different varieties of cookies, such as chocolate chip, double chocolate, and funfetti, placed on a speckled countertop.
Monthly Bake Box
Sweet Treats

Welcome to The Eager Alligator Bakery

Discover our passion for baking with customizable sugar cookie packages and a delightful rotating monthly bake box inspired by New Orleans and Appalachian flavors, using only the finest ingredients.

150+

Handcrafted Designs

The Eager Alligator Bakery's customizable cookies are a delight! Each bite reflects the passion and quality of ingredients. Highly recommend their monthly bake box!

Daisy G.

A large stack of cookie boxes is neatly arranged on two small tables. The boxes are uniformly divided into two colors: blue on the left and pink on the right. Each box has simple icon designs printed on them, and the background features a tiled wall with a light, neutral tone.
A large stack of cookie boxes is neatly arranged on two small tables. The boxes are uniformly divided into two colors: blue on the left and pink on the right. Each box has simple icon designs printed on them, and the background features a tiled wall with a light, neutral tone.

★★★★★

Customizable cookies and baked goods from us.

All goods are hand delivered locally.

Contact us!

theeageralligatorbakery@gmail.com

251-518-6071

© 2025. All rights reserved.